If you’re specifying steel tubing, it’s crucial to choose between structural tubing (ASTM A500) and mechanical tubing (ASTM A513/A519). Though they look similar, the differences in strength, precision, and application can make or break your project, affecting safety, fabrication costs, and code compliance.
🔍 What Is Structural Tubing?
-
Definition: Heavy-duty, load-bearing tubing designed for construction and structural applications.
-
Key Specs: Wall thickness is higher, with chemical and mechanical property requirements under ASTM A500 or A1085 eoxs.com+1longma-group.com+1reddit.com.
-
Typical Uses: Building frameworks, bridge support, columns, and heavy-equipment structures.
-
Best Choice When: Structural integrity and load resistance are essential.
🔍 What Is Mechanical Tubing?
-
Definition: Precision tubing ideal for machining and fabrication, built for dimensional accuracy, not structural capacity.
-
Key Specs: Tighter tolerances, smoother surface finish, made to ASTM A513 (or alloy versions like A519) tottentubes.com+1shop.machinemfg.com+1.
-
Typical Uses: Automotive shafts, conveyor rollers, furniture frames, and hydraulic components.
-
Best Choice When: Precision and machinability matter more than load-bearing strength.
⚖️ Key Differences at a Glance
| Feature | Structural (ASTM A500) | Mechanical (ASTM A513/A519) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Use | Load-bearing, support, structural integrity | Precision parts, machining, fabrication |
| Yield Strength | ≥ 50,000 psi (345 MPa) reddit.com | ~30,000 psi (205 MPa) |
| Wall Thickness | Thicker, heavy-duty | Thinner, lighter-weight |
| Dimensional Tolerances | Looser tolerances, basic geometry | Tight tolerances, fine corner radii |
| Surface Finish | Rougher, mill finish | Smooth, suitable for visible or precision applications |
| Typical Standard | ASTM A500, A1085 | ASTM A513, A519 |
| Example Applications | Bridges, columns, heavy frames | Chassis, shafts, rollers, tubing |
📚 Expert Insight from the Industry
-
According to Atlas Tube (A500 vs. A513):
“A500 tubing… includes material test reports (MTRs) with yield, tensile, elongation… A513 … needs tighter dimensional tolerances and smooth finishes” en.wikipedia.org+15atlastube.com+15atlastube.com+15.
-
A513’s Drawn-over-Mandrel (DOM) variation delivers nearly seamless quality and improved concentricity reddit.com+6reddit.com+6shop.machinemfg.com+6.
-
Reddit engineers note:
“The only difference between A500 tubes and A513 is A513 has tighter tolerances… Both steels are virtually identical in chemical composition” en.wikipedia.org+14reddit.com+14longma-group.com+14.
✅ How to Choose – Quick Guide
-
Need Load Capacity (≥ 50 ksi)? → Use A500
-
Require Precision & Finish? → Use A513 (or DOM variants)
-
Building vs. Fabrication? → Choose based on structural demands vs. machinability
💡 Why It Matters
-
Safety: A500 is engineered and certified for structural use.
-
Cost Efficiency: A513 can be significantly cheaper if high yield strength isn’t essential.
-
Fabrication Speed: Tighter tolerances of A513 reduce rework in machining.
-
Compliance: Using materials unsuitable for load-bearing could violate code.
🔧 Final Takeaways
-
Structural (A500): Ideal when strength, certifications, and load-bearing are critical.
-
Mechanical (A513/A519): Perfect for precision work, lighter structures, or aesthetic applications.
-
Always verify mechanical properties and tolerances against project needs.
-
Consult material test reports—especially when structural integrity is on the line.
